The Utica Common Council voted 5-4 Thursday to reject a local good cause eviction law, ending the city’s consideration of whether to adopt tenant protections authorized by New York state.
The law, passed by the state in 2024, allows cities to choose whether to opt in. In Utica, the proposed measure would have applied to tenants who follow their leases and pay their rent. Evictions or rent increases would have needed to be supported by a valid reason, such as nonpayment or property damage.
What the council considered
The proposal addressed the circumstances under which a landlord could remove a tenant or raise the rent. Under the measure described to the council, compliance with a lease and payment of rent would have provided tenants with a basis to remain in their homes, while specified conduct such as failing to pay rent or damaging property could have supported an eviction.
The council’s decision followed months of discussion involving tenants and landlords. After that input, members moved the proposal out of committee and brought it before the full council for a vote. The measure failed by one vote, with five council members voting against it and four voting in favor.
“We will continue to push for strong housing reform and regulation to address our housing crisis. The problem isn't going away, so the people that are working on the solution aren't going away. In fact, next year, I anticipate a lot of work around the State done by the housing movement, pursuing things like stronger protections for tenants and stronger rent stabilization measures, too.” — Senya Bequi, lead campaign organizer for the Central New York chapter of Citizen Action NY
Bequi spoke after the vote about continued efforts to pursue housing regulations and tenant protections across New York. The group’s Central New York chapter supported the push for the Utica measure.
- Vote: The council rejected the proposal 5-4.
- State law: New York’s 2024 law lets cities decide whether to adopt good cause eviction protections.
- Next meeting: The next Utica Common Council meeting is scheduled for Dec. 4.
The defeated proposal was one local response to ongoing debate over housing rules in Utica. The council’s vote leaves the city without the good cause eviction law considered Thursday. The next regularly scheduled council meeting is set for Dec. 4.